Hello dear
Welcome to Primo
Primo, located in the heart of New Castle, IN, is a culinary gem offering a diverse menu that highlights Italian classics and inventive dishes. Known for its house specialties like Cheese Ravioli, Fettuccine Alfredo, and Chicken Parmesan, each plate is crafted with care and flavor. Guests rave about the generous portions and the inviting atmosphere, which feels like a warm embrace. Notably, their drink selection shines, featuring local craft beers and expertly mixed cocktails, including the famed Espresso Martini. With vegan options that even non-vegans adore, Primo promises a delightful dining experience for everyone, making it a beloved staple in the community.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Cheese Ravioli
Guardian Rainbow Pop Pale Ale
Heretic Shallow Grave Porter
Metazoa Puppy Slumber Party Peanut Butter Porter
About
Primo
Welcome to Primo, a hidden culinary gem located on 1326 Broad St, New Castle, IN. This establishment is not just a restaurant; it's a community hub where flavors meld with a friendly atmosphere, leaving diners feeling like family each time they walk through the door.
Primo excels in offering an impressive variety of dishes that cater to diverse palates. From the tantalizing Salmon Risotto and the uniquely crafted Cajun Shrimp Pasta to the rich and hearty Prime Rib Sandwich, every bite at Primo is a testament to culinary excellence. Touted by local patrons like Chris Wilkey and Derek Gustin, the importance of flavor is clearly highlighted in each dish. Chris's recommendation of the blue cheese chips and the chicken parmesan sandwich emphasizes the restaurant’s knack for pairing comfort food with quality ingredients. Meanwhile, Kristie Inman shines a light on the unexpected vegan options, proving that Primo cares for all dietary preferences.
What really sets Primo apart is its vibrant drinking culture. Guests rave about an impressive selection of draft beers, including local favorites such as Sun King and The Guardian. The atmosphere thrives under the creative mixology of bartenders like Katie, who is known for her exceptional Old Fashioneds and Tommy’s celebrated Espresso Martini, ensuring that there's something for everyone alongside their meal.
There’s an undeniable warmth to the ambiance; it’s a place that invites you to linger, sip, and savor. The casual yet classy decor provides a perfect backdrop for enjoying your meal or catching up with friends. My personal highlights include the delectable Fettuccine Alfredo paired with steamed vegetables—a classic done right, as Ed Smith shared in his glowing review.
Primo makes it easy for diners to enjoy a leisurely lunch as well, with options like the Pick 2 that rival offerings from chains yet taste even better. Whether you're in the mood for a cozy dinner or a casual lunch, Primo promises a delightful experience that keeps customers coming back for more. Their commitment to quality food and customer satisfaction radiates through every plate served.
If you're in downtown New Castle, Primo isn't just a recommendation—it's a food enthusiast's destination. Come for the fantastic menu; stay for the heartwarming service. Your next favorite dish is waiting here at Primo.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Best draft beer selection in town. I highly recommend ordering the blue cheese chips and grabbing a beer from places like The Guardian, Sun King, and a ton of other great local breweries. Other favorites include the calamari, the salmon (they cook it really well), and my personal favorite the chicken parmesan sandwich. Other friends and family love the tenderloin and the pasta. If you aren’t a beer drinker, have Katie make you an old fashioned (she rocks at it and is a pretty great bartender for being the owner). I also recommend going at lunch and grabbing the Pick 2 with soup, salad, or half a sandwich. It’s like getting Panera only better. ”
“ Made reservations for 6p on a Friday but probably wasn't necessary judging by the open tables. We were quickly waited on and brought drinks. I would not recommend the water here. We started with the breadsticks with Alfredo. Those were excellent. I decided to try the Chicken Parmesan sandwich and my wife had the Cajun Shrimp Pasta. The sandwich was plenty big and tasted good. It lacked flavor so I probably should've added red pepper. The pasta dish was cooked well and had excellent flavor and a hint of spice. ”
“ While they don't advertise as a plant based restaurant, they have vegan options that are out of this world! ”
“ Primo has stolen my heart! From the amazing drink selection, to the vast and delicious menu, this is the place that calls you back for more. The best part of Primo? I feel like family every visit. Stop in downtown New Castle to try out their starters, pastas, pizzas, sandwiches, soups and more! (All from the heart) Don't forget to ask Tommy for his famous Expresso martini! ”
“ excellent food! fettuccine Alfredo and steamed vegetables. my large sized white Russian was perfectly made. classy clean decor with a comfortable casual dinning feel. I highly recommend it to anyone. 2025 my second visit a year later. Still excellent fettuccine Alfredo and Caprese , white Russian tasted great ! ”
“ Great food and great service. Husband and I had pasta and my kids had pizza. We will for sure come back. ”
“ First time eating here and it was a great dining experience. Every person that worked there was attentive to all customers. Food was delicious ”
“ Wow I'm so amazed I have celiac and I didn't get sick!! The owner, bartender, and chef took my disease very seriously. I have a new place to go every week! Good job guys, I wish I could give you 100 stars ”